CAL-OSHA Pressured?

You might have heard the scuttlebutt over the recent report released by Cal-OSHA. Quotes hit the news since the California Industrial Relations Department’s Occupational Safety and Health Division completed an investigation into the November 2006 Sea World killer whale incident involving Kasaka and trainer Kenneth Peters and said that swimming with captive orcas “is inherently dangerous and if someone hasn’t been killed already it is only a matter of time before it does happen.”

Many years later, emergency protocols to handle such incidents remain poor in many establishments. Just how to you handle a out-of-control orca? It is a tough challenge to address in an aquatic environment with the size, agility, and strength of an orca…I asked did the trainer have an air tank on–and wouldn’t you know that is one of the recommendations Cal/OSHA made.

What is disturbing about this whole issue is that after conversations with Sea World officials Cal/OSHA is CHANGING their report. Does it sound funny to you that Cal-OSHA is rewriting their report?

Mike Scarpuzzi (VP of zoological operations at Sea World) is quoted as saying they are the professionals. Since when does that exempt you from danger?

Least we forget about incidents involving killer whales such as the man who drowned in the orca tank in 1999 and not all captive killer whale incidents make the news or stay in our memories.

When I was offered a job to train orcas at Sea World, I had to think long and hard about it–and declined. Sea World coins terms and procedures regularly–and they keep changing over time. In the Frontline produced, “Whale of a Business” you can read some of the terms and about some of the killer whale incidents.

Some people tracked early killer whale incidents such as the one at Sealand in Canada who lost trainer Keltie Byrne to drowing after captive orcas made her into a play toy.

Working with predators is dangerous…don’t let anyone tell you otherwise. Do stuffed orcas and choreographed water work with these majestic animals make the public believe otherwise?

Maybe the spin mitigates the reality so much that everyone will believe it…incidents making the news seem to be up and you can read more of my comments at arkanimals.com

Animal News: Captive Attacks & Preparation

Okay, first I just have to say that this animal escape drill is naive. The speed, dexterity, and ferocity behind an animal escape can’t be duplicated by a human in an outfit. Drills are important but this one seemed to succeed in creating trauma for little children.

In the wake of the tragic death of Ashlee Pfaff, zookeeper at the Denver Zoo, the debate related to captive animals is again rearing its head. My whole career this has been an issue and it will remain so.

First, I belive the majority of people don’t care about what they don’t know, can’t see, can’t touch. Sometimes humans are afraid of what they don’t know or understand. Most certainly don’t understand the connection between all living creatures…meaning that what impacts the smallest will impact the largest.

Do I want animals in captivity–I don’t see any way around it–and so my whole career has been grounded in my relationships with captive animals and trying to improve the world they live in and get people give a damn, improve conditions, and get people to think outside of the small environment they call home.

One of the problems that has been increasingly disturbing is that people still want to think animals are their friends. That is the wrong idea. Animals are beautiful, majestic, powerful beings that need respect. They are fine tuned for survival. An animal person can have a good relationship with an exotic–but that doesn’t mean they won’t kill you or try to at some point.

A jaguar is not a domestic kitty. The sad death of Ashlee Pfaff doesn’t focus on the loss of the powerful predator–or the plight of his species and all those in the habitat he came from. It would be a waste of her life not to get people to look at why the animal is in captivity in the first place and the bigger picture.

As the Federal investigation into Ashlee Pfaff’s death begins I have to say that all the animal attacks I have witnessed have been due to human error.

Human error can mean a lot of things such as failure to monitor the animal’s emotional state, failure to secure or lock a gate, entering into an enclosure that was supposed to be empty but wasn’t, failing to take action to mitigate a situation, even design error or equipment failure. In zoos, most accidents seem to come down to the simple fact that someone made a mistake.

One of my college buddies lost her life entering into a tiger exhibit shortly after we graduated from the “Harvard of exotic animal trainers.” It was the first but not the last time I heard about the death of a colleague. I don’t know if it was her mistake or someone else’s mistake but the error was a deadly one and happens all too frequently.

In my career I always have double and tripled checked–even when someone else said they had already done so–and it has probably saved my life more than once. This latest incident is a reminder to all those working with wildlife to use diligence and be mindful of what you are doing at all times.

The animal community is saddened by this recent loss and most of us choose to work with animals and know the risk. We urge you to remember that wild animals are just that–and the jaguar is an apex predator and very good at the job of being just that.